Printable Version of Topic

Posted by: S3B 28/06/2012 - 17:06:28

S3B

"I had to choose, so do not be to offend by my judgment"

I thank mappers for the working sum and the great 9 maps in our 1st Contest ^^

Evaluation of the maps :

Visual appeal and attention to detail
Overall fun and playability
Lighting – Is the lighting convincing for the situation it’s used it.
Detail – Pretty simple to grasp.
Texture use – Do the textures in the map all fit, and flow together?
Model use – Do the models fit the map?
Optimization – How well does the map play
Build quality of map
Brush use – Did you use brushes well in the map?
Entity use – Did you use entities well in the map?
Design
Balance – Is the map fair for both teams?

[sep][/sep]

http://www.17buddies.net/17b2/View/Map/81658/cs_salvation.html

My judgement :

Rank : 9

Not very detailled, the map can be improve by using more textures.
The map's construction is simple.
Map too small for a Cs_map.

[sep][/sep]

http://www.17buddies.net/17b2/View/Map/81701/fy_17buddies_iles_canaries.html

My judgement :

Rank : 4

Very cool map and fun, near of the idea of the Contest : Sunny
This map lost points with the light... i can't see any shadows

[sep][/sep]

http://www.17buddies.net/17b2/View/Map/81702/de_17buddies_entra.html

My judgement :

Rank : 8

Well built, this map should have more textures, seems to be a 'de_inferno'.
Not very detailled, the map should be better with pretty models, and not crates.

[sep][/sep]

http://www.17buddies.net/17b2/View/Map/81717/de_brick_zone_17b.html

My judgement :

Rank : 7

Very 'cubic' map & not really a summer map. The map have a good layout.
I think this map is adapted to wars.

[sep][/sep]

http://www.17buddies.net/17b2/View/Map/81718/de_kassai.html

My judgement :

Rank : 2

This map is pretty, well built, with lots of possibility.
The ligths are awsome.
The map is a little too complex.

[sep][/sep]

http://www.17buddies.net/17b2/View/Map/81757/de_17b_emblem.html

My judgement :

Rank : 1

Well built, original and fresh.
Easy to learn, pretty and fun.
Lights are awsome (also).

[sep][/sep]

http://www.17buddies.net/17b2/View/Map/81766/de_17buddies_alexandria.html

My judgement :

Rank : 3

A lot of work in this map - Very real map
Well built, the map isn't difficult to learn.

[sep][/sep]

http://www.17buddies.net/17b2/View/Map/81767/de_encore_17b.html

My judgement :

Rank : 6

Simple map, with simple texture, not really a summer map.
But this map is perfect for Gungame or Deathmath Servers.
Easy to learn, fun and very speed.

[sep][/sep]

http://www.17buddies.net/17b2/View/Map/81771/de_drought.html


My judgement :

Rank : 5

A map well built, but with 2 or 3 textures
The lights are not so good, the color of light is different of the sky.